A comment posted on my blog recently by Susan expressed the hope that I would write more about the Forsyte Saga which I had mentioned in passing. I need very little encouragement to pontificate about anything so here goes....
The original Forsyte Saga was a BBC production in the late 60's which was so popular that public meeting places emptied on a a Sunday evening as everyone stayed in to watch the latest episode. While I was addicted like everyone else, it seemed to me then that I was the only person in the UK who found Irene, Soame's wife, the most irritating female character I have ever come across. I watched the remake of the Saga, on ITV a year or so ago, to see if I felt the same some forty years later and, yes, I did. I am not sure if this irritation was to do with the two actresses who played the role in both series, Nyree Dawn Porter and Gina McKee as, in my opinion, they were wildly miscast with Gina McKee being particularly poor, but I do not think that anybody could make a sympathetic figure of Irene.
First of all, I do take the background into account. Irene was more or less forced to marry Soames as she was poor, alone and really had no future other than marriage. I also take into account that a woman at that time had no rights at all and was considered her husband's property. The first book is, after all, titled A Man of Property, which, in this case was Irene. So, I know Irene was locked in an unhappy marriage with someone who was obsessively possessive and whom she came to loathe.
I should have sympathy with her, but I don't and have never been able to explain why. I think it might be because she is never endowed with any particular character by Galsworthy. She is just there. She acts as a catalyst for the narrative and is a shadowy figure throughout. Irene is always being spoken to, or about, she never seems to say very much herself but her presence manages to permeate the novel and effect all those around her. So a whistle stop tour of the story is as follows, with apologies for any inconsistences that may occur. I have not read the book for some 35 years.
Soames decides to build a house for his wife, hoping that this will improve their relationship. He hires a new young architect with whom Irene promptly falls in love. The architect, dismissing Soames as a philistine, ignores his instructions and over reaches the budget and changes plans without consultation. Soames gets a bit shirty about this, as one would, and in the end decides to take Bosinney, the architect, to court. Bosinney comes round to see Soames and arrives just as it is clear that Soames has abused his wife. Off he runs, straight under the wheels of a carriage and is killed. Needless to say, that is the end of the marriage and Irene leaves him.
Later in the saga, Irene goes to visit the house, Robin Hill, now owned by Old Jolyon, a member of the family who dislikes Soames intensely, becomes friends with him, bewitches his son, Young Jolyon and marries him. They have a son, Jon. In the meantime, the divorced Soames marries again, a somewhat sophisticated, cynical Frenchwoman, and has a daughter Fleur. Inevitably, once Fleur
and Jon grow up, they meet by accident and fall madly in love with one another. And, thus, the continuing Irene/Soames relationship affects another generation. Pressure is put on Jon by his father to give up Fleur, for his mother's sake, and he does. Jon and Fleur, though they marry others, are never really happy again.
Throughout the entire story Irene lurks in the background. She does not say much, but is a hovering influence over everything and causes endless unhappiness and misery. Soames never recovers from his love of her, Bosinney died because of her, her son Jon has an unhappy marriage because of her. My allegiance has always been to Soames. He is never given credit for his love of his family, the tender way he looks after his old father James, and takes care of his sister who is married to a wastrel. His love for his daughter, Fleur, is the light of his life and the knowledge that he has caused her misery and unhappiness because of his past action is a source of perpetual pain to him.
Eric Porter played Soames in the earlier version and Damien Lewis in the latest dramatisation. Though Damien Lewis was excellent, he lacked the necessary ability to make the viewer feel for his heartbreak and unhappiness. 'The night Soames died' as it was billed in all the newspapers back in 1967 is an evening I remember well. I was awash with tears at the end of the episode which was utterly heartbreaking. One of the all time great TV performances and it made the main BBC news that evening it had taken such a hold on the nation.
I have not read the Forsyte Sage for many years now, but I remembered the last lines as being incredibly sad and melancholy and affected me deeply. Galsworthy is fairly unfashionable nowadays with his writing ability somewhat denigrated, but it should be remembered that he won the Nobel Prize for literature so he can't have been that bad! No, I don't think he is exactly up there with Tolstoy or Dickens but just read these lines below and say they don't give you a pang. I dare you:
And only one thing really troubled him, sitting there--the melancholy craving in his heart--because the sun was like enchantment on his face and on the clouds and on the golden birch leaves, and the wind's rustle was so gentle, and the yew tree green so dark, and the sickle of a moon pale in the sky.
He might wish and wish and never get it--the beauty and the loving in the world!
See what I mean?
Recent Comments