Some eighteen months ago, Bryn Terfel pulled out of his contracted performances of the Ring Cycle citing his son's injury, fractured, crushed fingers and decided he wanted to be with his family. A certain Rupert Christian, amongst others, berated him for his actions but while most critics were angry, they pulled back from saying what the Telegraph arts writers said. This is one sentence from the whole article which truly appalled me with its narrow minded, old fashioned attitude.
"The show goes on though the bombs are falling; the enterprise is bigger than you are. There is no room for sentimentality: you have to be ruthless and put your personal life second. We don't know the details of your son's accident, but the boy has a mother and it's her job to be at the bedside." (My emphasis - Elaine)
He went on to say that if the injury had been more serious then Bryn's absence would have been understandable and acceptable but this was only 'minor'. So, if his son was seriously ill, that would have been all right then....
Bryn defended his decision vigorously, he was supported by some (including me but I am honest enough to admit that as I had decided not to buy tickets for this Ring as I loathed the production, I was probably more understanding than I might have been if I had shelled out several hundred pounds), not by others and during an interview this article was quoted to him. He looked the interviewer in the eye and made a reply along the lines of 'yes, I know who he is' and I thought at the time that if I was Mr Christian I would not go down a dark alley at night all alone.
So, what has Mr Christian got to say about Bryn the the Flying Dutchman after telling the Opera House that perhaps they should show him the door? See link below:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/culturecritics/rupertchristiansen/4799000/Der-fliegende-Hollander-at-the-Royal-Opera-House-review.html
One can only assume that Mr C did meet Mr B down a dark alley.....the words 'humble pie' come into mine, or perhaps 'grovel' or perhaps one should just view Mr Christian as a clear eyed critic who is viewing this from a purely artistic viewpoint, which bearing in mind the strictures of his first excoriation of Bryn, might very well be true.
And what did this critic think of it? Well, I am biased of course as I simply adore Bryn and have done for over 20 years when I saw him in Cardiff Singer of the World and heard him sing the act one entrance aria from Dutchman and he brought the house down. Since then I have seen him in Wagner, Verdi and Puccini and my admiration knows no bounds for this simply wonderful voice. The Flying Dutchman is one of Wagner's earlier operas and if I say it is full of stonking great tunes, don't misunderstand me, the Ring Cycle has all these as well, but they are just so much grander and mind blowing, Dutchman is more your 'ordinary' opera if you can understand what I mean. Well, I know what I mean.... There are also duets and a trio or two, not something abounding in the Ring, and it is all great stuff.
What I like about Bryn is the beauty of his soft singing, the warmth and shape of his tone, it sounds easy and expressive, his German is spot on and, well, he was simply wonderful. He did not overpower the other singers, he was not the star of the show, he was part of an ensemble and I felt this was a very unselfish portrayal. Yes, he got a huge round of applause at the end of the evening but I really felt that the audience appreciated this whole company approach and reacted accordingly. The new production was in a modern setting, not to my taste but then I am very old fashioned when it comes to opera productions, but very well done and the lighting and atmosphere almost converted me by the end of the evening. Never fails to amaze me and fill me with admiration, the sheer imagination and inventiveness of designers and producers and how they set everything and move the singers around to achieve the maximum effect.
Senta, the woman obsessed with the Flying Dutchman, is one of Wagner's annoying creations, well as far as I am concerned anyway, neurotic and, to me, a bit boring as heaven knows she does go on. Does have some great music though and the soprano, Anja Kampe, was pretty powerful and certainly made an impression. Her outpouring at the very end of the final scene made me tingle.
The main star of the evening though, was not the soloists, but the chorus. They were simply stunning, with a sound that knocked your socks off. Extra chorus employed for the ghostly crew of the Dutchman's ship and when the two were going it pinned you to your seat (do forgive all these cliches). Took a bow on their own at the end with the chorus master and rightly so. I have never heard the Covent Garden chorus sing so well.
When I have seen Dutchman in the past there has been an interval and two acts. Tonight it was billed as Romantische Oper in one act and that is how Wagner wrote it and that is how it was done at the Royal Opera House. In other words, straight through, two and a half hours, no break. Despite this being made clear in the programme, during the booking period, and also subscribers reminded by email, there were still some dozy people there who did not realise this and got very ancy, and nipped in and out, presumably to go to the loo or whatever, much to the annoyance of others. If one such had been sitting next to me, rest assured he/she would have been pinned to the ground and not allowed past me.
Glad I was that I had shelled out for a decent seat as not sure I would have made it up in the Amphi or in the slips. When I met Daughter No 2 before the start she had not realised this and blinked a tad, but then I pointed out to her that she had sat through and loved Gotterdamerung and the first act of this final opera in the Ring was the same length as the entire performance of Dutchman, and 'oh that's alright then'.
And so it was, a glorious evening. Next booking period has Bryn back as Scarpia in Tosca, so that is on my hit list, and I am looking forward to 2010 when he sings Hans Sachs in Die Meistersinger with the Welsh National Opera. If ever a man was born to sing a part, it is Bryn and Hans Sachs and I have become a friend of WNO purely so I can get my mitts on tickets which I am already assured are going to be the hottest in town.
Cardiff here I come.
Recent Comments