Last week I went to see Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street a 'musical' by Stephen Sondheim. I have put the word musical in inverted commas as there is an argument that this particular work can hardly be classified as such, but is more of an opera. The same was said years ago when Gershwin wrote Porgy and Bess. Both have been performed on opera stages and in musical theatres. On reading the programme for the performance I have just attended it is opined that Sweeney Todd is both; when it is produced in a musical theatre then it is a musical, in an opera house, it is an opera. This gets round the conundrum very nicely.
I have loved this work for years. I first saw it via a tv broadcast back in the 1980's of the New York production with Len Cariou as Sweeney and Angela Lansbury as a wonderfully macabre Mrs Lovett, the lady who persuades Sweeney to go into partnership with her. He will slit the throats of all his customers and pass them on to her and she will turn them into meat pies. Yes, I know this hardly sounds like light entertainment but somehow it works. Sweeney Todd is in reality Benjamin Barker who was transported for life to get him out of the way so Judge Turpin can seduce his wife who he has had an eye on for some time. She is ruined by him and ultimately dies leaving her daughter Joanna who is raised by the judge as his ward, though he has lustful thoughts towards her as well. When Benjamin Barker is rescued from the sea and returns under a different name to London, his plan is revenge.
My main reason for attending this particular production was, of course, Bryn Terfel who was playing the title role, but I think I would have gone anyway as this is a compelling work that I find fascinating each time I see it. I have seen several productions of Sweeney Todd now, including a performance at the National Theatre some years ago. This one at the newly refurbished Royal Festival Hall was a semi-dramatised concert performance which can sometimes almost be better than a fully staged theatrical one, as there are few props, little scenery and it is up to the performers to bring it alive.
It goes without saying that Bryn was magnificent. I think this man is a phenomenon, he seems to be able to sing everything. I have seen him in Tosca, in the Ring Cycle, The Flying Dutchman and now this and each time he brings total commitment to the role he is singing. One most powerful scene when he is singing of the revenge he wishes to wreak on all those who have been instrumental in his family's misfortunes, is truly terrifying with him giving this particular monologue the full operatic treatment.
My daughter, Helen, came with me as she and her sister are familiar with this score and have seen performances of it when they were children. We have discussed the fact that this was really not suitable fare for them and I wondered why on earth I and my husband had taken them to see it so often, but Helen said though looking back, she probably agreed with me, she had never found it frightening and thought it was a great work.
Sweeney Todd may be brutal and frightening but there are moments of tenderness and for those critics who say Sondheim doesn't write 'good tunes' just listen to I feel you Joanna, the love song to Sweeney's daughter by the young sailor and Nothing's Going to Hurt You sung by the simple minded Toby to Mrs Lovett who has taken him under her wing.
A truly wonderful evening and today to add to my joy, I have just read that Bryn Terfel, as well as tackling the Ring Cycle, has heard my dearest wish as he is to sing Hans Sachs in Die Meistersinger for the Welsh National Opera. I have been hoping for this for some time now and I am thrilled to bits so Cardiff here I come. Don't care if I have to cash in my Premium Bonds this is one performance I will not be missing.
Recent Comments